Home› Comics Talk Community - The On Topic Forum

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Sign In Register

Categories

Who do you think is the Greatest Supernatural Detective in comic?

JohnathanConstantineJohnathanConstantine Posts: 436
edited August 2012 in Comics Talk Community - The On Topic Forum
As those on the novel thread know, I've been on a Dresden Files marathon where I hit upon this question

'Who exactly is the greatest supernatural detective in comics?'

I've got a list myself that seemed to just expand on and on.

So, add characters I've missed and try and pick the best one. When that happens I think I'll try and get a poll up so we can figure it out.

The List

John Constantine, Hellblazer, Vertigo
Harry Dresden, Dresden Files, Dynamite Entertainment
Hellboy, Hellboy, Dark Horse
BPRD, Hellboy/BPRD, Dark Horse
Lobster Johnson, Hellboy/BPRD/Lobster Johnson, Dark Horse
Sir Edward Grey, Hellboy/BPRD/Witchfinder, Dark Horse
Deadman, Deadman, DC
Mina Murray, League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, Vertigo
Solomon Kane, Solomon Kane, Dark Horse
Ghost, Ghost, Dark Horse
Ghost Rider / Johnny Blaze, Ghost Rider, Marvel
Ghost Rider / Danny Ketch, Ghost Rider, Marvel
Blade, Blade, Marvel
Hannibal Kane, Marvel
Bloodstone, Marvel
· Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Comments

  • random73random73 Posts: 2,318
    Does Archie from Crossgen's Ruse count?
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • random73random73 Posts: 2,318
    Does Detective chimp count? And would you consider Dr. Fate and the Phantom Stranger "investigators"?
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • TorchsongTorchsong Posts: 2,794
    Batman. The answer is always Batman. :)

    From that list, I'd put Constantine up there, definitely.

    The greatest supernatural investigators are the Kurosagi Corpse Delivery Service, of course, but I realize they may not be as widely read as the above names.
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • steve_bryantsteve_bryant Posts: 96
    Hellboy. The answer is always Hellboy. :)
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • LibraryBoyLibraryBoy Posts: 1,803
    Chance Falconer from James Robinson's Leave it to Chance
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • wrecking_crewwrecking_crew Posts: 33
    Zatara

    Doctor 13...he's so steadfast in his Scully-ness that magic doesn't work on him. Also, hot daughter*

    G-men from Hell.



    *well, pre-New 52 anyway
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • HexHex Posts: 944
    random73 said:

    Does Detective chimp count?

    Detective Chimp would be first on my list.
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • DennisCuzinskiDennisCuzinski Posts: 265
    Well, she is not in comics (yet -- look for that in 2013), but I would give the nod to Misty Johnson, Supernatural Dick... http://www.amazon.com/dp/B004HB1WFK
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • TorchsongTorchsong Posts: 2,794
    There is one, and only one, supernatural investigation team to rule them all:

    Fred Jones
    Daphne Blake
    Velma Dinkley
    Norville Rogers
    and a certain Great Dane (no not Marmaduke!) we all love.

    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • Mr_CosmicMr_Cosmic Posts: 3,200
    Torchsong said:

    There is one, and only one, supernatural investigation team to rule them all:

    Fred Jones
    Daphne Blake
    Velma Dinkley
    Norville Rogers
    and a certain Great Dane (no not Marmaduke!) we all love.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mr4Ek08FEFs
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • JohnathanConstantineJohnathanConstantine Posts: 436
    edited August 2012
    Detective chimp would count @random73, but I would consider Dr Fate & Dr Strange as societies first.

    I also changed the thread's title to 'detective'. It's more about discovering & solving mysteries than spell power.
    random73 said:

    Does Archie from Crossgen's Ruse count?

    Anyone from any publisher at any time would work, for me.

    BTw, after reading Artifacts #19 I think Tom Judge neededs to be added to the list. Any conjecture?

    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • JohnathanConstantineJohnathanConstantine Posts: 436
    edited August 2012
    The List Revised

    John Constantine, Hellblazer, Vertigo
    Harry Dresden, Dresden Files, Dynamite Entertainment
    Hellboy, Hellboy, Dark Horse
    BPRD, Hellboy/BPRD, Dark Horse
    Lobster Johnson, Hellboy/BPRD/Lobster Johnson, Dark Horse
    Sir Edward Grey, Hellboy/BPRD/Witchfinder, Dark Horse
    Deadman, Deadman, DC
    Mina Murray, League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, Vertigo
    Solomon Kane, Solomon Kane, Dark Horse
    Ghost, Ghost, Dark Horse
    Ghost Rider / Johnny Blaze, Ghost Rider, Marvel
    Ghost Rider / Danny Ketch, Ghost Rider, Marvel
    Blade, Blade, Marvel
    Hannibal Kane, Marvel
    Bloodstone, Marvel

    Additions
    Sara Pezzini, Bearer of Witchblade Witchblade, Top Cow
    Tom Judge, Bearer of the Rapture Witchblade/Artifacts, Top Cow
    Detective Chimp DC
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • TorchsongTorchsong Posts: 2,794
    If you're going to throw Pezzini in there you should also throw in The Magdalena (Patience)
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • DoctorDoomDoctorDoom Posts: 2,586
    Detective Chimp.
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • EarthGBillyEarthGBilly Posts: 362
    Yeah, I gotta go with Detective Chimp. I mean, he and Batman consult each other, so he's gotta be up there.
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • JohnathanConstantineJohnathanConstantine Posts: 436
    edited August 2012
    The List Revised

    John Constantine, Hellblazer, Vertigo
    Harry Dresden, Dresden Files, Dynamite Entertainment
    Hellboy, Hellboy, Dark Horse
    BPRD, Hellboy/BPRD, Dark Horse
    Lobster Johnson, Hellboy/BPRD/Lobster Johnson, Dark Horse
    Sir Edward Grey, Hellboy/BPRD/Witchfinder, Dark Horse
    Deadman, Deadman, DC
    Mina Murray, League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, Vertigo
    Solomon Kane, Solomon Kane, Dark Horse
    Ghost, Ghost, Dark Horse
    Ghost Rider / Johnny Blaze, Ghost Rider, Marvel
    Ghost Rider / Danny Ketch, Ghost Rider, Marvel
    Blade, Blade, Marvel
    Hannibal Kane, Marvel
    Bloodstone, Marvel
    Sara Pezzini, Bearer of Witchblade Witchblade, Top Cow
    Tom Judge, Bearer of the Rapture Witchblade/Artifacts, Top Cow
    Detective Chimp DC

    Additions
    Doctor 13, DC
    Archie, Ruse, Crossgen
    The Magdalena, Top Cow
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • Chuck_MelvilleChuck_Melville Posts: 3,003
    Frankly, I would have handed it to Jim Corrigan, the Spectre -- who was not only an investigator, but jury, judge and executioner as well.
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • JohnathanConstantineJohnathanConstantine Posts: 436
    edited August 2012
    The List Revised

    John Constantine, Hellblazer, Vertigo
    Harry Dresden, Dresden Files, Dynamite Entertainment
    Hellboy, Hellboy, Dark Horse
    BPRD, Hellboy/BPRD, Dark Horse
    Lobster Johnson, Hellboy/BPRD/Lobster Johnson, Dark Horse
    Sir Edward Grey, Hellboy/BPRD/Witchfinder, Dark Horse
    Deadman, Deadman, DC
    Mina Murray, League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, Vertigo
    Solomon Kane, Solomon Kane, Dark Horse
    Ghost, Ghost, Dark Horse
    Ghost Rider / Johnny Blaze, Ghost Rider, Marvel
    Ghost Rider / Danny Ketch, Ghost Rider, Marvel
    Blade, Blade, Marvel
    Hannibal Kane, Marvel
    Bloodstone, Marvel
    Sara Pezzini, Bearer of Witchblade Witchblade, Top Cow
    Tom Judge, Bearer of the Rapture Witchblade/Artifacts, Top Cow
    Detective Chimp DC
    Kim Corrigan/The Spectre, DC
    Doctor 13, DC
    Archie, Ruse, Crossgen
    The Magdalena, Top Cow
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
Sign In or Register to comment.