Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Favorite "What If...?" Issue

2»

Comments

  • popestupopestu Posts: 782

    One I loved but have yet to see mentioned here is #44, What If Captain America Were Not Revived Until Today? Awkward title, but great story (and another Sienkiewicz cover... not his most eye-catching, but my first exposure to his work).

    Basically, Namor zigs instead of zags and never comes across Cap frozen in the ice. A few years later, when Nixon goes to China, someone disgusted with state of the nation frees 50s Cap & Bucky from their suspended animation, and their particular brand of violent jingoism is embraced by 70s Cap villainous mainstays like the Committee to Regain America's Principles (CRAP), the Secret Empire, William Taurey, and the like. America becomes a fascist state, most of the super heroes are driven into obscurity, "retirement", or underground as revolutionaries.

    And despite all that... the ending isn't entirely a bummer, because as the title promises, the real Cap does indeed return, and oh is he unhappy. :D

    This was the first issue of What If...I ever bought. I'm not sure where I got it but I loved the Cap vs Cap fight. This was my introduction to retcons and multiple Caps.
    image
  • bralinatorbralinator Posts: 5,967
    I've been grabbing the occasional copy of What If...? just to read, and unlike volume 1 of this series, volume 2 issues can usually be picked up for a buck or less at most comic shops. However, I've discovered that from the volume 2 series, issue #49 "What if the Silver Surfer Possessed the Infinity Gauntlet?" is very hard to find for less than $10 or $15 bucks at comics shops, if at all. A quick search for it on eBay has it regularly selling for between $25 and $80...!?!

    Does anyone have any insight as to why this particular issue is in such demand? It appears to be the most highly valued issue from the entire second volume of that series. I'm bewildered.
  • CageNarleighCageNarleigh Posts: 729
    edited March 2015
    No idea. But glad I have it if that's the case!

    FUN FACT: It was one of the first Marvel works (if not first comics works PERIOD) of Ron Marz! (We interviewed him recently on my podcast and I had to ask him about it while he was on since it's one of my favorite What If...? stories.)
  • bralinatorbralinator Posts: 5,967

    No idea. But glad I have it if that's the case!

    FUN FACT: It was one of the first Marvel works (if not first comics works PERIOD) of Ron Marz! (We interviewed him recently on my podcast and I had to ask him about it while he was on since it's one of my favorite What If...? stories.)

    Cool! I will check out the LanternCast tonight :)

    I think the speculation/price jump is probably just direcly related to the Marvel movies / Thanos connection. Don't recall there being any other What If...?'s related to Thanos / Infinity Gauntlet.
  • DoctorDoomDoctorDoom Posts: 2,586
    edited March 2015

    No idea. But glad I have it if that's the case!

    FUN FACT: It was one of the first Marvel works (if not first comics works PERIOD) of Ron Marz! (We interviewed him recently on my podcast and I had to ask him about it while he was on since it's one of my favorite What If...? stories.)

    Cool! I will check out the LanternCast tonight :)

    I think the speculation/price jump is probably just direcly related to the Marvel movies / Thanos connection. Don't recall there being any other What If...?'s related to Thanos / Infinity Gauntlet.
    Au contrare.....

    image

    image
  • HexHex Posts: 944

    No idea. But glad I have it if that's the case!

    FUN FACT: It was one of the first Marvel works (if not first comics works PERIOD) of Ron Marz! (We interviewed him recently on my podcast and I had to ask him about it while he was on since it's one of my favorite What If...? stories.)

    Cool! I will check out the LanternCast tonight :)

    I think the speculation/price jump is probably just direcly related to the Marvel movies / Thanos connection. Don't recall there being any other What If...?'s related to Thanos / Infinity Gauntlet.
    Au contrare.....

    image

    image
    Amazing! I don't think I have ever seen either of those!
    The Impossible Man one looks fun!
  • bralinatorbralinator Posts: 5,967

    No idea. But glad I have it if that's the case!

    FUN FACT: It was one of the first Marvel works (if not first comics works PERIOD) of Ron Marz! (We interviewed him recently on my podcast and I had to ask him about it while he was on since it's one of my favorite What If...? stories.)

    Cool! I will check out the LanternCast tonight :)

    I think the speculation/price jump is probably just direcly related to the Marvel movies / Thanos connection. Don't recall there being any other What If...?'s related to Thanos / Infinity Gauntlet.
    Au contrare.....

    image

    image
    I've never seen either of those! And in fact, neither of them are pulling that same kind of price tag... The mystery deepens...

    http://pages.ebay.com/link/?nav=item.view&alt=web&id=400856666764

    http://pages.ebay.com/link/?nav=item.view&alt=web&id=171218310022


    Heck, the entire Infinity Gauntlet series can be picked up for $50
    http://pages.ebay.com/link/?nav=item.view&alt=web&id=331506759263
  • I'll have to say this.
    image

    My first answer was this but I realised it wasn't a "What If" issue...
    image
  • Of the few that I have read the xmen ask what If the phoenix had not died is my favorit issue..I think it's number 37
  • fredzillafredzilla Posts: 2,131
    image
    image

    So... Quesada plagiarized?!?
  • bralinatorbralinator Posts: 5,967
    edited March 2015
    image

    One more comment about this issue. Unlike most What If...? stories, this one has a happy ending for a change. Very refreshing.

  • i_am_scifii_am_scifi Posts: 784
    edited March 2015
    Here are my top few issues:

    image

    image

    image

    And I'll actually put the last issue of What if? on there as well, as I would put money on it inspiring the team of "Next Avengers" that got an animated movie and has appeared in both Bendis and Hickman's Avengers' run.

    image

    Oh, and almost forgot one of the weirder ones that still sticks with me:
    image
  • fredzillafredzilla Posts: 2,131
    edited March 2015

    Here are my top few issues:
    image

    I like how you can clearly tell which heroes hooked up to help create this "new generation." Poor Thor...

Sign In or Register to comment.