For those that are interested in following the numbers (and, of course, these direct market numbers don't tell the whole story of what readers as the end user are actually buying, but I think they still say something) Diamond has released their
Top 500 of 2015.
I find the graphic novel/collected edition charts the most interesting part of it. Unlike #1s, those more often reflect sales of books that are either published in prior years, but continuing to be in demand, as well as showing what titles got enough buzz and reviews (as usually the trade is solicited a few months or more into people actually reading the title) to reflect the success of what something actually turned out to be, rather than what retailers hope a #1 issue will do, if you know what I mean.
Comments
(And I cheer for that, not out of some general 'corporations down indies up!' sentiment because, don't get me wrong, I'm loving the Star Wars books from Marvel. Rather, the fact that there are creators, at least some, making a living at Image with their own work, including the revenue streams from perennial trade and digital sales as audiences continue to hear about and discover their work, just means there is more chance of more of that kind of work existing. I think we are in a golden age of creator-owned books representing a variety of genres right now, especially at Image. So seeing that they can compete in the trade market even against the Big 2 event books and Star Wars is a good sign to me.)
Marvel's core line is getting reset every 11 to 22 months. The sales fall back to what the previous series sold at after about issue 3 of the relaunch.
DC relaunched their entire line in 2011 (closing in on 5 years), and has not relaunched since then. They've tried new titles, but that's completely different than what Marvel has done.
The Batman titles are so prominent in this list... because Batman is really popular. DC is seeing the effects of Marvel killing it in the box office, I mean why else would Spider Gwen and Deadpool outsell Justice League and Superman?
Actually DC needs to adopt Marvel's thing of rebooting every year. It's effective. As a fan I'm ready to give up long issue numbers. Just give me some way to know the real issue number so that when I'm collecting I can know what I have and don't have. Put it in tiny letters on the back page. Do some type of year based scheme like 2016-1, just give me a way of putting a chronology together without pulling my hair out. Do that and reboot every 3 months for all I care.
Do you think it was:
1) Digital comics aren't collectible - can't sell a digital back issue.
2) Those who want it, largely have it already
3) Retro Chic - physical books are coming back with younger crowds
4) Tablet sales have declined - fewer new customers
5) Marvel Unlimited and similar subscription services
I think it's a combination of all 5, but I'd love to know how many people have signed up for the all-you-can eat subscriptions like Marvel Unlimited or Comixology / Amazon Prime, which may be why sales of issues are actually down. Why pay cover price for a digital comic (DC) when you can have 17,000 back issues 6 months older and further back for $69 a year?
1) Decline in tablet sales
2) Already have it (though this is heavily tied to the decline in tablet sales)
3) Subscription services
...
...
...
4) Desire for physical books
5) Collectibility
I think 4) and 5) have very little impact on sales in relation to the first three items.
Any insight on how many Marvel U subscribers there are?
We wont' ever see those numbers, but they have to be good enough, as they are adding more old books every week. USUALLY something connected with an upcoming story or event, but this week they added an old Tigra mini-series that even I had forgotten about.
That might get me to sign back up. I've loved MU, but I got so behind on my reading that I let it lapse. But might get back in.
Netflix has similarly affected both cable television and video rental during it's run.
With comics at $4, I just buy the Marvel Unlimited. It's good not to have the clutter, and I have saved HUNDREDS of dollars. Too bad DC can never do it because of royalty contracts and Comixology's is mostly for introducing people to books. It's like Kindle Unlimited...streaming and choice is the future.
I'm a bit hesitant to embrace those June numbers as a sure sign of renewal too since they only show how many books retailers bought. Not a clear indicator of how many books consumers actually purchased. With Civil War II and Rebirth slightly skewing things, those numbers may not be perfectly accurate. Thankfully Diamond lowers the DC numbers considerably to figure in return-ability, but I actually expect those numbers to potentially bump up with the way that reboot is being received. On the other hand, the way Marvel handles things, I'm betting many of us will be able to find several issues of CWII in the quarter-bins by Christmas.
While I am hopeful with those increased June numbers, I still believe on a long enough timeline, paper comics are going to continue to decline. These numbers are an interesting topic, for sure.
More: https://www.yahoo.com/tech/great-tablet-gold-rush-over-165927100.html
Again, does anyone have an informed guesstimate or care to speculate how many people subscribe to Marvel Unlimited?