The Geeks turn up their collars and head down to the cold, hard streets of Reviewsville in this Off the Racks episode, featuring Marvel's Power Man and Iron Fist #1, Dynamite's Shaft: Imitation of Life #1, and Image's Snowfall #1. Plus bonus reviews!
Listen here! And check the CGS App for the return of Bonus Content!
Comments
In regards to Tombstone’s appearance, @Adam_Murdough, yeah, he should have had the filed teeth, but I think the overall appearance was fantastic. All too often Tombstone has been drawn so generically that he appears like just another white supervillain. I think it's telling that if you Google “who should play Tombstone,” the first actor that pops up is Ron Perlman. It may be somewhat stereotypical for an African-American character to have larger lips, but when that character also has white skin and a crew cut, I think giving Tombstone a facial structure that is more identifiable as “black”—not just the lips, but the cheekbones and brow—is a good idea.
I liked Power Man and Iron Fist. Hadn't really read any of it before this, so I can't comment on how Danny Rand's personality was portrayed here. I give it a buy-row.
I'm with @nweathington on this buybuybuy
It's hard for me to put a finger on what this style of artwork is like.. It seems like James Harren's work if anyone knows him (he is currently drawing Rumble at Image, written by John Arcudi). Harren also did an arc on Brian Wood's Conan run, which was how I got interested in him.
Anyway, PM&IF is definitely one of my faves so far among ANAD Marvel titles.
Snowfall: Yeah, BORROW: I wish I hadn't ordered the 2nd issue. I agreed with what everyone said. The art didn't impress me, the world-building was derivative, and I got bored. And I think the art definitely reminded me of Quitely, but not as good.
Shaft: So far I'm agreeing with Dani, BORROW: And I ordered the whole mini-series, too. I thought the artwork was kinda plain. Almost cartoony. And the story was kind of roundabout, not finding it's footing...ever. I found that in the end I didn't care that much. I'm also thinking that I wish the story went further along. Maybe my low rating is because, unlike Chris, I never really got into the Shaft movies (but I do like the song!)
Power Man & Iron Fist: LOW BUY: Another one that I ordered at least the first 3 issues of. The artwork bothered me a bit (both cartoony and sketchy), but overall it didn't take me out of the story which was good and in fact, perhaps helped illustrate the street level feeling of the story. Oh...thanks Murd for the info about the Marvel Handbook size of Danny Rand and Luke Cage. That helps.
Archie: BORROW. I've read the first two issues and it was pretty good. Didn't grab me, though.
The Vision: Agreed! But I think it's King's BEST series. BUY!
Black Widow: Like PANTS (not a rating), I'm also looking forward to getting it...
Starve: BORROW? Never heard of it...Bourdain? Wasn't he in The Big Short? (cameo)